Napoleon Series Archive 2009

Re: Canister
In Response To: Re: Canister ()

Kevin

If you read what I had written, you will see that i asking how did period observers actually know what was happening to the cannister round in the tube given that a) they could not see it B) due to this any conclusion was suppostion.

How can you make an imperical statement of fact about an event you cannot see?

Period sources on how a cannister worked is informed guess work at best. They knew the effect of cannister as that could be observed, BUT they did not know how that effect was brought about. period commentators were merely guessing.

Another anaology. The Greeks believed as did most of the educated world till fairly recently their was nothing smaller than the atom and the atom could not be divided. Modern science shows it can. I beleive my horse analogy to be fairly accurate regarding how supposed 'fact' from the past is prooven wrong by modern imperical observations.

Twenty period sources can offer their opinions on to how a cannister round, but they cannot offer fact on how the cannister ruptured in the gun tube. Their is a difference between opinion presented as fact and imperical data gained from observation.

All I am saying is, how did the period oberservers know for a fact how cannister ruptured in the gun tube? to my mind they did not know imperically what happened, if you can offer hard imperical data on how a cannister ruptures I would be pleased to red it.

Messages In This Thread

Howitzers
Re: Howitzers
Re: Howitzers - for Kevin to answer
Re: Howitzers
Ere wie ere toekomt
Re: Howitzers
Re: Howitzers
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister *LINK*
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Case Shot
Re: Case Shot
Re: Case Shot
Re: Case Shot
Re: Case Shot
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister *LINK*
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Prussian Ordnance and Artillery
Re: Prussian Ordnance and Artillery
Prussian Ordnance not of the 7YW
Re: Prussian Ordnance not of the 7YW
Re: Prussian Ordnance not of the 7YW
Re: Prussian Ordnance not of the 7YW
Line or Guard Artillery
Re: Line or Guard Artillery
French artillery tactical doctrine
Re: French artillery tactical doctrine
Re: French artillery tactical doctrine
French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Doctrine vs Common Practice
Re: Doctrine vs Common Practice
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Materials by Hermann von Müller.
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica *LINK*
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Arrows in the Quiver
Friedland, 1807 by Maj. A. F. Becke, RA.
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
Re: French Artillery Commanders and Tactica
absence of evidence is not evidence of absence
Re: French artillery tactical doctrine
Re: French artillery tactical doctrine
The British gunner by J. Morton Spearman.
Re: The British gunner by J. Morton Spearm
Re: The British gunner by J. Morton Spearm
Re: The British gunner by J. Morton Spearm
Re: The British gunner by J. Morton Spearm
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Re: Howitzers and Canister
The Null Hypothesis
Re: The Null Hypothesis
Re: Howitzers and Canister
Cannister and Hail Shot
Re: Cannister and Hail Shot
Quote from De Scheel (1800)
Re: Quote from De Scheel (1800)
Re: Quote from De Scheel (1800)
Re: Quote from De Scheel (1800)
Re: Quote from De Scheel (1800)
Different constructions of cannister
Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Which particular design???
Re: Which particular design???
Re: Which particular design???
Re: Which particular design???
Re: Which particular design???
Sources
Re: Which particular design???
Re: Which particular design???
Re: Which particular design???
Re: Which particular design???
Re: Which particular design???
Re: Which particular design???
Re: Which particular design???
Re: Which particular design???
M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
Re: M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
Re: M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
Re: M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
Re: M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
Trick Phrase. :\
Re: M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
Re: M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
Re: M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
Re: M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
Re: M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
Re: M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
System AnXI
Re: System AnXI
Re: System AnXI
Re: System AnXI
French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
M1775 Garrison Guns
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Asked and Answered...
Re: Asked and Answered...
Re: Asked and Answered...
Superiority?????
Re: Superiority?????
Re: Superiority?????
Techology changes over 50 years
Re: Techology changes over 50 years
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
So 25 is better than 20 interesting *NM*
Conundrums...
Re: Conundrums...
Re: Conundrums...
Quoting from Adye 1801
Re: Quoting from Adye 1801
Re: Quoting from Adye 1801
Re: Conundrums...
Re: Conundrums...
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: French Artillery of 1824
Re: M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
Re: M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
Re: M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
Re: M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
Re: M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
Re: M1765 Cannister from De Scheel
Things melt especially when heated.
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Problems of translation
Re: Problems of translation
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Thank you for this summary.
Re: Thank you for this summary.
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
White metal = tinned iron
Re: White metal = tinned iron
Re: White metal = tinned iron
Re: White metal = tinned iron
Re: White metal = tinned iron
Dollezcek (1872)
Things melt especially when heated. *LINK*
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Re: Things melt especially when heated.
Re: Which particular design???
French Experimental Design
Re: French Experimental Design
Re: French Experimental Design
Re: Which particular design???
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Re: Canister
Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Forming square from column
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Re: Guard infantry operated in 8 pelotons
Ducking a Canister Can
Re: Ducking a Canister Can
Re: Ducking a Canister Can
Re: Ducking a Canister Can
Re: Ducking a Canister Can
Re: Quote from De Scheel (1800)
Re: Quote from De Scheel (1800)
Re: Cannister and Hail Shot
Re: Cannister and Hail Shot
Re: Cannister and Hail Shot
Re: Cannister and Hail Shot
Re: Cannister and Hail Shot
Re: Cannister and Hail Shot
Re: Cannister and Hail Shot *LINK*
Re: Cannister and Hail Shot
Re: Cannister and Hail Shot
Spherical Case [Shrapnell]
Re: Spherical Case [Shrapnell]
Re: Spherical Case [Shrapnell]
Re: Spherical Case [Shrapnell]
Kartätschkugeln *LINK*
Re: Kartätschkugeln
Re: Kartätschkugeln
Light and Heavy Cannister
Re: Light and Heavy Cannister
Re: Light and Heavy Cannister
Re: Light and Heavy Cannister *LINK*
Re: Spherical Case [Shrapnell]
Re: Cannister and Hail Shot
Re: Cannister and Hail Shot
Re: Cannister and Hail Shot
Canister = basket
Re: Canister = basket
On the Use of Field Artillery on Service.
Re: Howitzers
Re: Howitzers
Re: Howitzers
Re: Howitzers
Re: Howitzers
Spherical Case [Shrapnell]
Re: Howitzers