Napoleon Series Archive 2009

Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
In Response To: Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland ()

Howie,

If an historical event is presented in a secondary work with primary evidence, then that evidence is primary within the secondary work. If Becke is quoting Napoleon, then that portion of Becke's work is primary, and hence contemporary. There are many secondary works (not Becke's in this case) which are full of primary source material, so much so that they can be classed as a primary work even though they have been authored/edited by a later author. Saski is an excellent example, as is Girod de l'Ain in his work Grands Artilleurs. Both of those books are loaded with primary source material which outweighs anything the listed author says in them.

Sincerely,
Kevin

Messages In This Thread

SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Dix ans de mes souvenirs militaires, de 1805-1815.
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
Re: SÚnarmont at Friedland
SÚnarmont at Friedland: New Doctrine?
changing the universal sentiment ...
Changing the universal sentiment: did it? How?
Re: Changing the universal sentiment: did it? How?
Re: Changing the universal sentiment: did it? How?
Re: Changing the universal sentiment: did it? How?
General Ruty
Re: Changing the universal sentiment: did it? How?
Re: Changing the universal sentiment: did it? How?
Re: Changing the universal sentiment: did it? How?
Senarmont and change *LINK*
The Camp At Boulogne.