Napoleon Series Archive 2011

you mean it is not dead yet...just let it go...
In Response To: Broussier's Division ()

G’Day Gents

I feel that we all agree that MacDonald used a formation that was called a Colonne Vuide for the assault of his great body of troops. With that said, I could end this thread. But what I would like to do is attempt to determine the disposition of each regiment within the Colonne Vuide.

Does anyone have the following documentation?

Broussier’s divisional report of 7 July 1809 (I am hoping that since John stated, “These are absolutely invaluable” that he has a copy)

Journal MacDonald’s report 7 July 1809

Armée Française: 1er Régiment d'Infanterie, 1889

John mentioned that the 92e was reunited on the 10 of July, -during the same time that Lamarque also detached six battalions.

Nevertheless in the Memoires de Massena Volume VI, page 415, it mentions that the 9e and one battalion of the 84e were deployed, and the other two battalions and 92e were in colonne.

Now the 1er Division can lead with the left or right, thus the numerical sequence will change accordingly, and I can live with the 9e deployed as long as the entire 92e was united, otherwise the numbers do not add up.

I can even live with the fact that Colonel Penne was wrong when he states that they were formed to the right of the 92e which was deployed.

I must then presuppose we must leave if up to Broussier’s divisional report made on the 7th of July.

As for Lamarque, I finally found someone who actually talked to him on the subject. But I feel that it is I, who shall be needing a semi frizante - served cool in the summer. And as Hans – Karl so elegantly put it “schwere Kost”...

But first we have to deal with Broussier.

Best Regards
Art

Messages In This Thread

Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Vox...
Re: Général instructions.
Re: Général instructions.
Colonne Vuide. Carré Vuide
Re: Colonne Vuide. Carré Vuide
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Buat
Re: Buat
Re: Buat
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: MacDonald's Report.
Re: MacDonald's Report.
Re: MacDonald's Report.
Re: MacDonald's Report.
Re: MacDonald's Report.
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: "... the investigation that General Koch did."
Re: "... the investigation that General Koch did."
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Martinien Online.
Complete Martinien Online. *LINK*
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
French Infantry Officer Casualties during the Napo
Re: French Infantry Officer Casualties during the
Of Possible Interest.
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
92e Ligne on the 6th of July
Résumé de l'historique du 93e régiment d'infanteri
Re: Résumé de l'historique du 93e régiment d'infan
Actually, ....
Historique du 92e régiment d'infanterie.
Re: 92e Ligne on the 6th of July
Re: 92e Ligne on the 6th of July
Re: 92e Ligne on the 6th of July
Re: 92e Ligne on the 6th of July
Re: 92e Ligne on the 6th of July
Re: 92e Ligne on the 6th of July
Re: 92e Ligne on the 6th of July
Historique du 112e régiment d'infanterie de ligne.
Re: Historique du 112e régiment d'infanterie de li
Re: Historique du 112e régiment d'infanterie de li
Re: Historique du 112e régiment d'infanterie de li
Histoire du 9e régiment d’infanterie de ligne.
Re: Histoire du 9e régiment d’infanterie de ligne.
Re: Historique du 112e régiment d'infanterie de li
Re: Historique du 112e régiment d'infanterie de li
Broussier's Division
you mean it is not dead yet...just let it go...
Re: you mean it is not dead yet...just let it go..
Re: you mean it is not dead yet...just let it go..
Re: you mean it is not dead yet...just let it go..
Re: you mean it is not dead yet...just let it go..
Re: you mean it is not dead yet...just let it go..
Re: you mean it is not dead yet...just let it go..
Re: Historique du 112e régiment d'infanterie de li
Re: Historique du 112e régiment d'infanterie de li
Re: Historique du 112e régiment d'infanterie de li
Re: Historique du 112e régiment d'infanterie de li
Re: Historique du 112e régiment d'infanterie de li
Re: Historique du 112e régiment d'infanterie de li
Re: Historique du 112e régiment d'infanterie de li
Re: Historique du 112e régiment d'infanterie de li
Re: Historique du 112e régiment d'infanterie de li
Re: Historique du 112e régiment d'infanterie de li
Re: 92e Ligne on the 6th of July
Re: 92e Ligne on the 6th of July
Re: 92e Ligne on the 6th of July
93e Regiment
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram
Re: Marshal MacDonald at the Battle of Wagram