Napoleon Series Archive 2015

Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...

And what 'character assassination' would that be?

Bernadotte was an enemy of his superiors and his actions in 1806 and 1809 brought disgrace to himself.

Marmont's treasonous actions in 1814 were dishonorable and were negatively viewed by Ney, Caulaincourt, and other senior French officers.

That isn't 'character assassination' it's an assessment of the facts.

There are frequent apologists for both Bernadotte and Marmont, and what they did or failed to do (the same can be said about Dupont) and I have found that those who continually offer apologies or reasons why their actions are acceptable usually are anti-Napoleon.

K

Messages In This Thread

Saxon memoirs - Buhle
Good press for Bernadotte
Re: Good press for Bernadotte
Re: Good press for Bernadotte
Re: Good press for Bernadotte
Re: Good press for Bernadotte
Re: Good press for Bernadotte
Why wasn't the sentry taken out and shot?
Re: Why wasn't the sentry taken out and shot?
Re: Why wasn't the sentry taken out and shot?
Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
The iron cage
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
Re: Too Bad the Sentry Missed...
S.A.R. Charles Jean / Prince Royal de Sude.
BERNADOTTE REVISITED
A New King and His 'Old' Men
Titeux, Titeux, Titeux.
Re: Titeux, Titeux, Titeux.
Re: Titeux, Titeux, toujours Titeux.
Re: PDF FILE OF ARTICLE.
Re: Titeux, Titeux, Titeux.
You, sir, are a man of action!