Napoleon Series Archive 2015

Re: What a nasty and silly thing to say

You're a little quick on the draw there, Roy. And it appears to me that you're shooting with blanks.

I would suggest that a Russian general being onvolved in a plot to murder the ruling sovereign and overthrow the government in favor of the Tsar's son, who knew of the plot, is distinctly dishonorable and does bring dishonor upon the entire Russian officer corps.

And Bennigsen wasn't the only Russian officer involved in the plot and murder.

And your analogy is a false one. The Union officers concerned were not attempting to murder and/or overthrow the president of the United States.

I would suggest that you get hold of David Hackett Fischer's Historians' Fallacies. It would be of great help to you in your future endeavors.

Messages In This Thread

New-Berthier, l'ombre de Napoléon
Re: New-Berthier, l'ombre de Napoléon
Re: New-Berthier, l'ombre de Napoléon
Re: New-Berthier, l'ombre de Napoléon
Re: New-Berthier, l'ombre de Napoléon
Re: New-Berthier, l'ombre de Napoléon
Re: New-Berthier, l'ombre de Napoléon
Did N. invade space?
Re: New-Berthier, l'ombre de Napoléon
Re: New-Berthier, l'ombre de Napoléon
Re: New-Berthier, l'ombre de Napoléon
Re: New-Berthier, l'ombre de Napoléon
What's the bias operating here?
Re: What's the bias operating here?
Re: What's the bias operating here?
Re: What's the bias operating here?
Re: What's the bias operating here?
What a nasty and silly thing to say
Re: What a nasty and silly thing to say
Re: What a nasty and silly thing to say
Re: What a nasty and silly thing to say
Nope I don't think I was quick on the draw
Re: Nope I don't think I was quick on the draw
Re: Nope I don't think I was quick on the draw
Re: Nope I don't think I was quick on the draw
Re: Nope I don't think I was quick on the draw
Re: Nope I don't think I was quick on the draw
Re: Nope I don't think I was quick on the draw
Re: Nope I don't think I was quick on the draw
Re: Nope I don't think I was quick on the draw
Re: New-Berthier, l'ombre de Napoléon
Re: New-Berthier, l'ombre de Napoléon
Berthier and the Grasy Knoll
Re: New-Berthier, l'ombre de Napoléon
The New Residence (Royal Palace of Bamberg)
Re: The New Residence (Royal Palace of Bamberg)
Re: The New Residence (Royal Palace of Bamberg)
Re: The New Residence (Royal Palace of Bamberg)
Die Neue Residenz and no assassins
Historical Libation Investigations
Re: Historical Libation Investigations
Re: Historical Libation Investigations
Re: Historical Libation Investigations
Rauchbier tour
Re: Historical Libation Investigations
Re: Historical Libation Investigations
Re: The New Residence (Royal Palace of Bamberg)
Re: The New Residence (Royal Palace of Bamberg)
Re: The New Residence (Royal Palace of Bamberg)
Thank you HKW ...
Re: New-Berthier, l'ombre de Napoléon
Berthier ...