Napoleon Series Archive 2015

Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.

There seem to be two alternative versions: one that Napoleon gave the order and Berthier failed to pass it on, which I doubt, and one that though several people suggested it Berthier wouldn't do anything without a direct order which Napoleon failed to give. As far as I can find out both versions are unsupported by evidence.

Susan

Messages In This Thread

Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Thiers
Re: Thiers
Re: Thiers
Re: Thiers
Re: Thiers
Re: Thiers
Re: Thiers
Colonel Montfort/Moutfort
Re: Colonel Montfort/Moutfort
Re: Colonel Montfort/Moutfort
Re: Colonel Montfort/Moutfort
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Charles François Dulauloy, 1761-1832.
Re: Colonel Montfort/Moutfort
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Joseph de Puniet de Monfort, 1774-1855.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Joseph de Puniet de Monfort, 1774-1855.
Grabowski
Re: Grabowski
Re: Grabowski
Re: Grabowski
No You Wouldn't.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Be wary of using Elting
Re: Be wary of using Elting
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Aster
Re: Aster
Re: Aster
Re: Aster
Re: Aster
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
MacDonald
Re: MacDonald
Re: MacDonald
Re: MacDonald
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: is Berezina a victory ?
Crossing the Berezina
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Berthier off the hook
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
au contraire
Re: au contraire