Mack may have been a bright person, as Napoléon was was well, in contrast to the later he was a failure in 1805 - did you the book by Kraus - der Feldzug von 1805 - Ulm - or is your opinion only based on the disertation
Der unglückliche Mack“
„Aufstieg und Fall des Karl Mack von Leiberich“
Ernst Rainer Gramm??