Napoleon Series Archive 2015

Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.

Macdonald did not just stroll out: if you took the trouble to read his account you will see that he had considerable difficulty getting across three separate river branches but one thing he did not mention was any problem with the ground in between them.

Your other posting with the quotes from Elting is the same prejudiced and ill-informed bullshit we have come to expect from that source. Read some original sources for once!

Susan

Messages In This Thread

Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Thiers
Re: Thiers
Re: Thiers
Re: Thiers
Re: Thiers
Re: Thiers
Re: Thiers
Colonel Montfort/Moutfort
Re: Colonel Montfort/Moutfort
Re: Colonel Montfort/Moutfort
Re: Colonel Montfort/Moutfort
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Charles François Dulauloy, 1761-1832.
Re: Colonel Montfort/Moutfort
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Joseph de Puniet de Monfort, 1774-1855.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Joseph de Puniet de Monfort, 1774-1855.
Grabowski
Re: Grabowski
Re: Grabowski
Re: Grabowski
No You Wouldn't.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Be wary of using Elting
Re: Be wary of using Elting
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Aster
Re: Aster
Re: Aster
Re: Aster
Re: Aster
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
MacDonald
Re: MacDonald
Re: MacDonald
Re: MacDonald
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: is Berezina a victory ?
Crossing the Berezina
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Berthier off the hook
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
Re: Berthier and the bridges, 17 Oct 1813.
au contraire
Re: au contraire