Napoleon Series Archive 2016

Re: Official sanction of local leaders

Franz was no longer in Vienna, but he was still free and legitimate sovereign of Austrian Empire with full power on his army, administration and government. Occupation of the capital city did not change the personal power of sovereign, nor the allegiance of his subjects.
No Regency was possible except by personal will of the sovereign (Marie-Louise regencies of 1813 and 1814), or if he could not exerce his will (King Georges). It did apply to the whole State, not to a former province.

Would a regency have replaced the Tsar in Russia because Poland or even Moscow was invaded by France ?

More, full approval of uprising is one thing, to nominate a man to lead it is another. No Austrian official document nominally legitimated Hoffer's command. And to lead an armed force without a government commission was, by the laws of the period, subject to death penalty.

Tyrol rose up because there was a legitimate Bavarian government according to international treaty signed by Vienna. French forces were involved later.

Legitimacy, again by the international laws of the time, was a matter of recognition of territorial sovereignity between head of State, not fulfilment of people's wish.

Andreas Hoffer uprising was certainly more than justified. It was not legal.

Messages In This Thread

Sir Sidney Smith
Re: Sir Sidney Smith
Re: Sir Sidney Smith
Re: Sir Sidney Smith
Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
What is war good for ?
Re: What is war good for ?
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Oh, the injustice
Historical Inquiry
Re: Historical Inquiry
Perhaps This Will Help...
Re: On the Other Hand...
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Murder is murder
Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Palm
Re: Palm
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
British Military Justice
Re: British Military Justice
Admiral Byng - a better example
Re: Admiral Byng - a better example
Re: Admiral Byng - a better example
Re: Admiral Byng - a better example
Re: British Military Justice
Re: British Military Justice
Re: British Military Justice
Re: British Military Justice
Re: British Military Justice
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Justice
Re: Justice
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death *LINK*
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Russian censorship under Alexandre Ier *LINK*
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Source for the Lefebvre anecdote
Re: Source for the Lefebvre anecdote
Re: Source for the Lefebvre anecdote
Re: Source for the Lefebvre anecdote
Thanks, another slight variation
Re: Thanks, another slight variation
Re: Thanks, another slight variation
Re: Thanks, another slight variation
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: The Military Oath
Re: The Military Oath
Re: The Military Oath
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re... worth a look?
Re: Re... worth a look?
Caulaincourt: a reliable source now?
Re: Caulaincourt: a reliable source now?
Re: Caulaincourt: a reliable source now?
Re: Caulaincourt: a reliable source now?
Re: Caulaincourt: a reliable source now?
Re: Caulaincourt: a reliable source now?
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Official sanction of local leaders
Re: Official sanction of local leaders
Re: Official sanction of local leaders
Re: Official sanction of local leaders