Napoleon Series Archive 2016

Re: Caulaincourt: a reliable source now?

Yes. I've read a number of accounts of the events of 1814. It was certainly a complicated affair. Overall, it seems to me that 1814 was a huge success for all involved in that Paris was not raised and relatively few lives were lost on all sides. The only real loser was N, which, under the circumstances, seems only proper. Calls of treason regarding some of the French generals only looks to be small potatoes in the larger view. N's luck had finally run out. He was cooked, doesn't really matter who stuck the fork in him.

I was just curious at how Caulaincourt's memoirs as a reliable source suddenly seemed to rise in the opinion of some folks when they were so strongly condemned concerning earlier events regarding N's cold-blooded plans for the invasion of Russia.

Messages In This Thread

Sir Sidney Smith
Re: Sir Sidney Smith
Re: Sir Sidney Smith
Re: Sir Sidney Smith
Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
What is war good for ?
Re: What is war good for ?
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Oh, the injustice
Historical Inquiry
Re: Historical Inquiry
Perhaps This Will Help...
Re: On the Other Hand...
Re: Allís Well, That Ends Well.
Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Re: Allied Abject Cruelty
Murder is murder
Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Palm
Re: Palm
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
British Military Justice
Re: British Military Justice
Admiral Byng - a better example
Re: Admiral Byng - a better example
Re: Admiral Byng - a better example
Re: Admiral Byng - a better example
Re: British Military Justice
Re: British Military Justice
Re: British Military Justice
Re: British Military Justice
Re: British Military Justice
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Justice
Re: Justice
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death *LINK*
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Russian censorship under Alexandre Ier *LINK*
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Dynasties.
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Source for the Lefebvre anecdote
Re: Source for the Lefebvre anecdote
Re: Source for the Lefebvre anecdote
Re: Source for the Lefebvre anecdote
Thanks, another slight variation
Re: Thanks, another slight variation
Re: Thanks, another slight variation
Re: Thanks, another slight variation
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: The Military Oath
Re: The Military Oath
Re: The Military Oath
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re: Et Tu Marshal?
Re... worth a look?
Re: Re... worth a look?
Caulaincourt: a reliable source now?
Re: Caulaincourt: a reliable source now?
Re: Caulaincourt: a reliable source now?
Re: Caulaincourt: a reliable source now?
Re: Caulaincourt: a reliable source now?
Re: Caulaincourt: a reliable source now?
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Treason and Rebellion are Punishable by Death
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Murder is murder
Re: Official sanction of local leaders
Re: Official sanction of local leaders
Re: Official sanction of local leaders
Re: Official sanction of local leaders