Napoleon Series Discussion Forum

Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies

The rebels took armed action against French troops in garrison.

The real question is 'what would you expect a French commander to do in these circumstances?'

It seems to me that you are judging events in the late 18th century in a combat zone by 21st century standards. Historically, that presents both a false and a prejudiced viewpoint. The commanders' first responsibility is to ensure the security of his own troops. That's called, in modern parlance, force protection.

Or, are you just making yet another attempt to disparage Napoleon and blame him for everything that happened from 1792-1815?

Messages In This Thread

Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
How dare you describe me as tall!
Re: How dare you describe me as tall!
Re: How dare you describe me as tall!
Re: How dare you describe me as tall!
Re: How dare you describe me as tall!
Re: How dare you describe me as tall!
Re: How dare you describe me as tall!
Re: How dare you describe me as tall!
Re: How dare you describe me as tall!
Re: How dare you describe me as tall!
Re: How dare you describe me as tall!
Re: How dare you describe me as tall!
The Big Corporal?
Re: The Big Corporal?
Re: The Big Corporal?
Re: How dare you describe me as tall! *LINK*
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Nationalism and Nationalists
Re: Nationalism and Nationalists
Re: Nationalism and Nationalists
Re: Nationalism and Nationalists
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Re: Comparison of Belligerents' Foreign Policies
Shakspear.
Re: Shakspear.
Re: Shakspear.
Re: Shakspear.
Re: Shakspear.
Abraham Lincoln.
Re: Abraham Lincoln.
Mao Zedong .
Al Capone
Tertullian.
Re: Tertullian.
Re: Tertullian.
Descartes.
Re: Descartes.
Re: Descartes.
Re: Shakspeare.